Ok I know that this discussion is pretty much over but I think that I came up with what could be a great sequal to outlaws!
All the other western games have amazing graphics (I think that the graphics have a big part in it.) But they are all seriouse and almost depressing looking. I think that the cartoony cutscenes from Outlaws is a great example of what the graphics and world should look like. If you have ever played the game you might have noticed that the world around you is more of a realistic kind of look with the textures making some of the wood and brick look beat up and rough but when you reload your Characters hand is the same cartoonish comic look. I think that the whole world around you should have the same look. Kind of like a cell shading kind of thing. Here are some examples of what I mean:
Just western but same concept.
"The Simple truth is that we've
lost control of our own borders,
and no nation can do that and survive"