Recommendation for new forum achievement

[Kuuki]

as I made my tid-bit statement in the new XWA 1yr thread:
http://lucasforums.com/showthread.ph...58#post2762158

A new forum achievement "Once in a Blue Milk Moon"

To be given to those actual Veteran Members to the forum, whom have said achievement whom do in fact on their regular basis, where it isn't a 'spread out' per daily posts, but they have their posts so ill-regularly that they are regulars but yet still have less then 1k (or adjusted count of...) posts.

Idea for icon design: the same square, but with a tall glass of white liquid on an angle with some of the fluid 'dripping out' of it, with an almost white background

[RC-3556]

White liquid....... And as it happens I do have minecraft.

[Qui-Gon Glenn]

I like it! Funny, not one that everyone can achieve, not one that people will "chase"... a trophy that people can earn for just being themselves

I second Kuuki's motion for the "Once in a Blue Milk Moon" badge... I can hear Kyle Katarn awarding it

[Sabretooth]

I third this.

You have my sword!

[Arannor]

Sounds like a good idea to me. You have my support!

[Working Class Hero]

This is stupid.

[Det. Bart Lasiter]

I agree. Forum achievements should be reserved for outstanding feats of foruming and bestowed in a solemn ceremony conducted in black robes.

[Arannor]

^Does that require everyone to chant in Latin and smack themselves in the heads with boards?
reference>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7wc55oXWf8

[Kuuki]

yes. yes we all do that. we have been for YEARS.

[Darth InSidious]

Originally Posted by Riothamus

^Does that require everyone to chant in Latin and smack themselves in the heads with boards?
reference>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7wc55oXWf8

You're doing it wrong. Now this...

YouTube Video

... this is how it's done.

[Lynk Former]

Don't most people over at XWA already have the 10 year badge, Scar?... What more do you want?

It took me awhile to understand what the hell you were trying to say in your opening post, but it seems... redundant.

[Kuuki]

well Lynk, I think a bit of the best explanation goes to "Qui-Gon Glenn", which I believe I do have a little bit of a problem in "clearly" explaining my ideas from time to time.

The idea is not exactly if someone would post irregularly before 1k (or what ever agreed that number of posts) but merely the time of regularly to make his/her posts given that said person has been a member for X-years

It would have to be at least a forum veteran with X amount of posts with X period 'known' (year amount)
And of course this requirement would be have to limited to a small number of posts.

if it were a minimum than anyone over the 5yr mark would be qualified. but if people whom do post regularly with an maximum X post count, means that 'post pumping' can not EVER be achieved by people like you or me (Lynk).

By default, with my idea, we are currently disqualified from said achievement.

As of right now I can say a couple of names
http://lucasforums.com/member.php?u=12940 < Luka_YJK (the main reason why)
http://lucasforums.com/member.php?u=82529 < (Rogue For Hire (whom since 2003 does not have any vet badges)

[Darth Avlectus]

What about people who voluntarily (or as reprimand by staff) had their post count nerfed?

Are we giving badges to all the inactive people once they hit 5 years or do they need to have been active for some time? What ratio or criteria would you use to figure that out?

[Kuuki]

I say any thing that is limited by staff disqualifies be default. that should be rather obvious

The idea is more on: active community 'just' irregularly 'but' constant

which, of course this throws out Rogue For Hire, because until he starts posting regularly (and I mean continuously regularly) even he is disqualified.

the award should be for someone whom is regularly interested but not able continuously enough to pust daily to rank up at least a pre-agreed amount, but still remain active for the minimum 5yr achievement.

that is the idea.

Like I mentioned, like people with around my post count and more, can not *ever* have the achievement.

and of course when I post "X" as what ever, it literally means 'what ever is agreed upon" period


(sry lemme edit tomorrow if possible to make more sense, if needed)

[Lynk Former]

@ Scar: Luka has both the 10 year and Forum Veteran badge. I'm pretty sure I gave the forum veteran badge to him and Niner gave the 10 year badge to him... as for RfH, yeah it looks like he got overlooked... but not necessarily because there's no badge that suits him, rather because no one bothered to ask in the badge recommendation thread and have it seconded by someone who has been around here long enough to recommend it.

The forum veteran badge was made, at least in my mind, for folks who are remembered as being a part of LF's history, not by how much they have posted. Also, it's not like the mods scour the forums to find people to give badges to... that's kind of why we have the badge recommendation thread.



But yeah... I really don't see the point in this badge at all.

[Jae Onasi]

Love the badge title/art idea. I'm not sure if we should reward people for being under a certain post count, since we don't have one for being over a certain post count, other than the user title, and that's not a badge anyway. Hopefully I'm not forgetting anything, though.

I think we should shoot for rewarding quality, anyway.


That being said, the name and badge art idea is awesome, and I wouldn't mind seeing it used in some fashion.

[mimartin]

I also have a suggestion for a badge. The Odd Nine Toes Badge – Given to those that only have nine toes and post only on odd days. Oh this missing toe must be on the left foot and it cannot be self-inflicted.

[Darth Avlectus]

How about ones related to social groups? Or how about non gaming subjects where a member shows expertise? I.E. we have plenty of people all over that are knowledgeable about modifying and/or building computers.

[Lynk Former]

Isn't that what the Notable Contributor badge is for?

[Darth Avlectus]

That it is, I'm talking about above and beyond that. Notable contributor is a prerequisite, then they get custom achievement badges as prestige. I.E. You, lynk, have your own site for reviews and such maybe you get a commentary badge, or someone could contribute to cosplay since I know we have lots of anime and manga fans, then we have computer experts among the rest of us mere computer users. Maybe someone with a fanfic badge could get another achievement for most well canon researched, another for most moving piece, stuff like that.

So custom/specialized merit badges is what I'm suggesting. Custom ones I know we have done on a rare basis. So I guess just prestige on top of what we already have.

I know people are going to gripe about having to do more work for another badge but in a way it's carving out a niche and making a name for yourself.

Just...offering ideas, make of it what you will.

[Pho3nix]

I wish you people would create that moderator kiss-ass badge sometime

[Det. Bart Lasiter]

you people? what the **** kind of racist **** is that

[Qui-Gon Glenn]

Originally Posted by Jae Onasi

I think we should shoot for rewarding quality, anyway.

Yes, this is the element that was missing. The poster is an irregularly regular contributor who doesn't always speak up, but gets heard like EF Hutton when she does, because it is good/funny/informative/cool. And the behavior is the same, over an extended amount of time... not a ton of posts, happen in short spurts here or there, gaps in activity, but it has been like that for 'x' years.

I am still a n00b relatively, and honestly no one right now I can think of is a candidate for the badge. That is good. It is an oddball title.

Originally Posted by Jae Onasi

That being said, the name and badge art idea is awesome, and I wouldn't mind seeing it used in some fashion.

Really the main reason why I like it. Just being honest

[Kuuki]

Quality
-------
Quantity

[Pho3nix]

Originally Posted by Det. Bart Lasiter

you people? what the **** kind of racist **** is that

I call 'em like I sees 'em

[Det. Bart Lasiter]

they're people too, man

[Darth Avlectus]

The **** is that? >_>

[Ctrl Alt Del]

Originally Posted by Pho3nix

I wish you people would create that moderator kiss-ass badge sometime

What about the Double Standard badge?

[Lynk Former]

I wish you people would create that Whiny annoying little... badge sometime... oh wait, I'm the one who makes all the badges lol.

[Ctrl Alt Del]

You're no fun, Lynk.

[Lynk Former]

No, I just make fun of everyone else

[Pho3nix]

Originally Posted by Ctrl Alt Del

What about the Double Standard badge?

What are you insinuating?

[Darth Avlectus]

I wish there was a forum games champion badge since I'm obviously not funny. Like Tommy DeVito.

[mimartin]

Originally Posted by GTA:SWcity

I wish there was a forum games champion badge since I'm obviously not funny. Like Tommy DeVito.

Cheer up GTA, if you will point out a post where you were actually funny, I'll nominate you for the Jesters Badge.

[Mav]

Snarky. Comment.

[Liverandbacon]

Reads: ...... people who have been on forum for long time ........ irregular posting...... still regular part of community.

Hey, that's me!

Reads: .... good/funny/informative/cool posts

Or not. We don't need no stinkin' badges!

[Darth Avlectus]

Originally Posted by Liverandbacon

We don't need no stinkin' badges!

No?

Then I guess we need furries--I have a little experimentation to do. Hand me the pliers.