What if Padme had lived?

[Gerevick]

To the present day, I believe the Star Wars universe could have been enhanced if Padme had remained a part of it. The continued conflict between her and Anakin would have added more possibilities to the overall story. As a way for Darth Vader to properly assert his dominance, Padme would have served him well. I extend an open invitation to hypothesize what could have happened had Padme lived. For better or worse, there are many things that could have, I think.

[Sabretooth]

If she had lived, I hope the first thing she'd do is find a doctor with you know, real credentials, who doesn't explain things away as "she has lost her will to live".

[cafiwam]

I don't think having Padme in the Original Trilogy would have really "enhanced" things, especially in the first two films. In "A New Hope" and "Empire Strikes Back" we aren't supposed to sympathize with Vader, and are meant to see him as more of an inhuman and unfeeling monster. Having Padme in those films would ruin part of the menacing feeling we got from Vader when those movies first came out and he might not have been as effective as a villain as he was.

Hypothetically if she was in the original trilogy, there would have been no reason to give up Luke and Leia and they would have been raised by Vader and the Emperor. The entire story would have to have redone, with perhaps Luke rebelling against his father and turning away from the life of a sith.

[Gerevick]

Originally Posted by cafiwam

Hypothetically if she was in the original trilogy, there would have been no reason to give up Luke and Leia and they would have been raised by Vader and the Emperor. The entire story would have to have redone, with perhaps Luke rebelling against his father and turning away from the life of a sith.

Indeed. Such a reality would have been more inspiring than the one created by Padme´s death. Had she lived, the spirit of rebellion against the Galactic Empire would have been stronger and the fate of the galaxy a more natural one. We would have seen Padme´s partisan soul versus Vader´s imperial one and regardless of who would have won, we would have seen a purer, more flawless story unfold.

[Totenkopf]

Padme had to die so we could get this bit....http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3F1d3...eature=related

[Pho3nix]

I don't know, she probably would have joined the Rebellion

[Gerevick]

Originally Posted by Pho3nix

I don't know, she probably would have joined the Rebellion

What would Vader have done to fight Padme if she did this? Would he he have opposed her directly, or would he have tried to capture Dared Janren and her sister Sola and threaten their lives if Padme didn´t submit to him, as he did to the Apprentice using Juno Eclipse in TFU II?

[Pho3nix]

Originally Posted by Gerevick

What would Vader have done to fight Padme if she did this? Would he he have opposed her directly, or would he have tried to capture Dared Janren and her sister Sola and threaten their lives if Padme didn´t submit to him, as he did to the Apprentice using Juno Eclipse in TFU II?

Hard to say, but he'd probably do a combination of those. He might even blow up Naboo just for kicks.

[Gerevick]

Originally Posted by Pho3nix

Hard to say, but he'd probably do a combination of those. He might even blow up Naboo just for kicks.

He would resort to such an extreme action? If Vader were to, how would he justify it to Padme?

[Klw]

Vader would be unrecognizable if Padme had lived. He turned to the Dark Side for her sake; his passion for her supplied him with the anger and the determination to reject the Jedi and challenge death. It was her death that turned him into a docile, cynical apprentice who, as far as we know, gave up his dreams and aspirations. It destroyed his spirit far more than the loss of his limbs.

If Padme had lived, Vader would almost certainly have challenged the Emperor's rule early on. He would have continued to be obsessed with her to the exclusion of obeying Palpatine. Given time, this obsession could have turned him back to the Light Side. Love can work both ways, as seen at the end of the Return of the Jedi.

Despite this, if Vader had not lost his duel to Obi-Wan in such spectacular fashion, Palpatine probably would have wanted to keep Padme alive to act as a carrot for Vader, baiting him to keep exploring the dark side of the force out of his perverted love for her. But since Vader was a broken man, the Emperor was most likely happy to use her death to snuff out his apprentice's spirit and ensure that he would never try to overthrow his master. Little did he know that Padme's son would soon come and restore Vader's lost passion, giving him a reason to be more than just an apprentice.

I think that Padme's presence would not so much enhance the Original Trilogy as preclude it. The role of Luke Skywalker would become less compelling; even unneeded.

[noizer]

Originally Posted by Klw

Vader would be unrecognizable if Padme had lived. He turned to the Dark Side for her sake; his passion for her supplied him with the anger and the determination to reject the Jedi and challenge death. It was her death that turned him into a docile, cynical apprentice who, as far as we know, gave up his dreams and aspirations. It destroyed his spirit far more than the loss of his limbs.

If Padme had lived, Vader would almost certainly have challenged the Emperor's rule early on. He would have continued to be obsessed with her to the exclusion of obeying Palpatine. Given time, this obsession could have turned him back to the Light Side. Love can work both ways, as seen at the end of the Return of the Jedi.

Despite this, if Vader had not lost his duel to Obi-Wan in such spectacular fashion, Palpatine probably would have wanted to keep Padme alive to act as a carrot for Vader, baiting him to keep exploring the dark side of the force out of his perverted love for her. But since Vader was a broken man, the Emperor was most likely happy to use her death to snuff out his apprentice's spirit and ensure that he would never try to overthrow his master. Little did he know that Padme's son would soon come and restore Vader's lost passion, giving him a reason to be more than just an apprentice.

I think that Padme's presence would not so much enhance the Original Trilogy as preclude it. The role of Luke Skywalker would become less compelling; even unneeded.

verry interesting theory

[Gerevick]

Originally Posted by Klw

Vader would be unrecognizable if Padme had lived. He turned to the Dark Side for her sake; his passion for her supplied him with the anger and the determination to reject the Jedi and challenge death. It was her death that turned him into a docile, cynical apprentice who, as far as we know, gave up his dreams and aspirations. It destroyed his spirit far more than the loss of his limbs.

If Padme had lived, Vader would almost certainly have challenged the Emperor's rule early on. He would have continued to be obsessed with her to the exclusion of obeying Palpatine. Given time, this obsession could have turned him back to the Light Side. Love can work both ways, as seen at the end of the Return of the Jedi.

Despite this, if Vader had not lost his duel to Obi-Wan in such spectacular fashion, Palpatine probably would have wanted to keep Padme alive to act as a carrot for Vader, baiting him to keep exploring the dark side of the force out of his perverted love for her. But since Vader was a broken man, the Emperor was most likely happy to use her death to snuff out his apprentice's spirit and ensure that he would never try to overthrow his master. Little did he know that Padme's son would soon come and restore Vader's lost passion, giving him a reason to be more than just an apprentice.

I think that Padme's presence would not so much enhance the Original Trilogy as preclude it. The role of Luke Skywalker would become less compelling; even unneeded.

Agreed. I will make use of this for my host´s own narrative. Already I have made many attempts to influence his creative development, but this offers me a fresh perspective to work with. At present, a universe in which Padme had lived and created an alternate timeline is in the works.

[madgirl7734]

if Padme had lived, Aniken/Darth Vader would have been terribly abusive and she might have become suicidal. it would have left plot room for Luke and Leia to find out who their mother is and try to help her. On the other hand, she was about 10 or 20 years older than him and i kind of find that disturbing.

[starwarzchick112]

If Padme had lived, Vader would probably turn back to the light.

[evilhazardz]

Originally Posted by madgirl7734

On the other hand, she was about 10 or 20 years older than him and i kind of find that disturbing.

She was only 5 years older than Anakin.

Anyway, I think Padme being in the originals would have ruined it so much that they would no longer be good movies.
The reason why the OT is so good is because they establish a plot, they have a guy who is just an everyday man who at first lives a normal life but gets dragged in to these circumstances, eventually Darth Vader becomes a villain who has an actual reason to be a antagonist (blew up Alderaan, tries to blow up Yavin, killed Obi-Wan) and we get the events of the galaxy explained to us through Luke because he's also new to all of this stuff, so we relate to why Luke needs to kill him, because even though he's scared he has no other choice.
The shock that Vader is Luke's father is suprising because we portray Vader as the villain and we're not sympathetic towards him, but with Padme still alive, Vader would have no reason to stay on the Dark side, Luke wouldn't be the average joe, Han would probably never be included and the tension would be gone from all of the movies.
How Vader was redeemed is much more entertaining and important than how he became Vader, because we've been with Luke through the whole journey and we want him to succeed and we want him to defeat the sith.