Who trained who

[duster]

A question.Why does Obi-Wan say that Yoda trained him in episode 5 and 6 since it was Qui Gon Jin in episode 1?Did Lukas made a small error here in the plot?

[jeffcorn]

Well here is just a guess, but maybe since we see Yoda with the younglings in Episode 2 maybe when Obi-wan was a youngling Yoda helped train him.

[duster]

Originally Posted by jeffcorn

Well here is just a guess, but maybe since we see Yoda with the younglings in Episode 2 maybe when Obi-wan was a youngling Yoda helped train him.

Yeah.That's most likely the explenation.Mabye younglings go through basic traning through him and then get trained by another master who will serve also as an example of the jedi knight.Thank's mate.

[Mandalore5]

That's what The Jedi Path says (though there was a different Grand Master when that was written) - younglings are trained as a group by members of the High Council, then when one is ready, they are taken by a Jedi Knight or Master for one-to-one training in the field.

[Alexrd]

Originally Posted by duster

A question.Why does Obi-Wan say that Yoda trained him in episode 5 and 6 since it was Qui Gon Jin in episode 1?Did Lukas made a small error here in the plot?

This scene was made purposely to explain that:

[duster]

Got it.Thanks guys.

[battle111]

Yeah like Alexrd sed that scene explains all

[sirNemanjapro]

Originally Posted by Alexrd

This scene was made purposely to explain that:

I find it hard to believe that Yoda is a kindergarten teacher. Lucas has demoted a great Jedi to a kindergarten teacher. I watched all the movies, but, that scene him "working" with the kids. Is there anyone else there to dose jobs?

It just doesn't work for me. I guess someone told Lucas about that hiccup after the Episode I, so he was trying to patch everything up.

[Alexrd]

Originally Posted by sirNemanjapro

I find it hard to believe that Yoda is a kindergarten teacher.

He's one of the Jedi who instructs Younglings.

Originally Posted by sirNemanjapro

Lucas has demoted a great Jedi to a kindergarten teacher.

No, he didn't.

Originally Posted by sirNemanjapro

I watched all the movies, but, that scene him "working" with the kids. Is there anyone else there to dose jobs?

Of course. Do you think those are the only Younglings in the whole Order?

Originally Posted by sirNemanjapro

I guess someone told Lucas about that hiccup after the Episode I, so he was trying to patch everything up.

Or, you know, he actually trained Jedi for 800 years.

[Mandalore5]

Plus, surely it would make sense to have the best Jedi train those new to the order, so they can be sure their masters aren't giving them wrong ideas (like C'Baoth teaching Jinzler in Outbound Flight, or C'Baoth teaching Luke in the original Thrawn Trilogy)?