Kotor III or Jedi Knights 4 - Page 2

tmwmodchaser · 12-20-2006, 08:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by InyriForge

JK series is dead in the water, as far as I'm concerned. Jedi Academy was the nail in the coffin.

While I would rather see a Kotor III, I must point out that you are slightly wrong. >_>

Dunno bout you, but I think the darkside ending was more of a cliffhanger, but that was just a personal opinion of mine. I would love it to decide whether Jaden was evil or not. If you choose Jaden good, you go on as Jaden trying to wipe out the last of the Imperials and the Sith.

But, if you choose Jaden marked as evil, you go on as Kyle Katarn trying to put an end to Jaden and the Imperials.

Stopping the releases of either game would be foolish as to how popular they are.

I'm sorry if I offended you while pointing that out, I just felt that needed to be said. >_>

Zerimar Nyliram · 12-23-2006, 04:19 PM

Both. And it would be JK3, not 2. (JA was a spinoff, just like MOTS. The numbered series stars Kyle.) I'm a fan of both.

The titles I hope to see are:
Knights of the Old Republic III: The Jedi Masters (I have no idea why, I think think it's a fitting title since the last one was The Sith Lords.)
Jedi Knight III: The Yuuzhan Vong War

aner21 · 03-13-2007, 03:02 PM

I really enjoyed JA. It could've been so much better, but I thought it was better than JK in the fight sequences (the combos for example) but only there. And I know I'll get hate male for this but I find Kotor's turn based combat system sooo boring

..
I'd love if they incorporated JA real time fighting to K3 or at least allow that option for people who don't enjoy "let's make a chart of actions to my character" sort of a fight. That and the fact you can't really move in the game. OB's a rpg and you have almost complete freedom to move your character, while in the kotor series you can... walk and... choose between right an left, kind of

Jediphile · 03-13-2007, 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aner21

I really enjoyed JA. It could've been so much better, but I thought it was better than JK in the fight sequences (the combos for example) but only there. And I know I'll get hate male for this but I find Kotor's turn based combat system sooo boring

..
I'd love if they incorporated JA real time fighting to K3 or at least allow that option for people who don't enjoy "let's make a chart of actions to my character" sort of a fight. That and the fact you can't really move in the game. OB's a rpg and you have almost complete freedom to move your character, while in the kotor series you can... walk and... choose between right an left, kind of

No. No real time in KotOR. Ever!

Not that you don't have a right to your opinion, you certainly do, but there is a vocal KotOR fanbase who play ONLY because the games are turn-based and not real time.

By all means, let them do JK4 in real time. Heck, I might even play it.

But KotOR is turn-based and should remain so, because the alternative takes away from the rpg-experience IMHO - I want my character to succeed or fail on the basis of how I built him during character creation and the game itself, not because of how good or bad I am at pushing buttons.

**Jae Onasi** · 03-15-2007, 12:59 PM

Heh, asking this question in a Kotor forum pretty much ensures the results are going to be incredibly biased.

So, I made sure to add my vote to the many for Kotor. I love the RPGs--there are so many different things you can do to make the game different every time.

PoiuyWired · 03-15-2007, 04:58 PM

JK ftw!! What on Earth is kotor anyways...

I mean, Hack! This is a kotor forum. Obviously kotor is to win out. Its like asking people here if they want a new star wars game or a new star trek game.

Jediphile · 03-15-2007, 07:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PoiuyWired

JK ftw!! What on Earth is kotor anyways...

I mean, Hack! This is a kotor forum. Obviously kotor is to win out. Its like asking people here if they want a new star wars game or a new star trek game.

Or the JK forum whether they should do JK4 or KotOR3...

EDIT: Actually, I think I'd actually prefer a new Star Trek game over a new Star Wars game... Though only if it's Star Trek: Bridge Commander II.

KyleOfHarpenden · 03-19-2007, 06:38 PM

yeah it was very stupid to put this in a kotor forum but no one is ever really on the jk forum so it would just be dead there if that makes any sence :s but the results are clear a kotor game kotor has a better story jk is better for online that my opinion though

Sabretooth · 03-20-2007, 05:37 AM

I think it'll be okay to break off the Jedi Knight franchise, becuase it was essentially an action game and you can make plenty of saber-swinging adventure games. (This statement is an exception, if they're planning on taking Kyle's story further)

On the other hand, KotOR has a strong storyline, a stronger (and wider) fanbase. Besides, the Jedi Knight series feels more or less, complete. KotOR doesn't. So that's why we need KotOR more than JK.

But to be honest, I would prefer a sequel to X-Wing/TiE over anything else.

Jediphile · 03-20-2007, 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sabretooth

But to be honest, I would prefer a sequel to X-Wing/TiE over anything else.

X-Wing/TIE-fighter don't need sequels plotwise. A sequel to X-Wing Alliance would be great, though - there were a few plots left unfinished in that game, presumably for the sake of a sequel that was then never made. Heck, any game by Lawrence Holland/Totally Games would be great. The last few, X-Wing Alliance and Star Trek: Bridge Commander were both great, but were forsaken by the publishers in spite of their success, and I haven't a clue why. Anyone know what Holland/Totally Games are doing these day btw?

PoiuyWired · 03-20-2007, 08:15 PM

A X-Wing series game would be nice though. Well trying to take on world devistators.

Jediphile · 03-20-2007, 10:22 PM

^^

Didn't we already do that in Rogue Squadron?

SilentScope001 · 03-20-2007, 11:36 PM

You know, technically, we already got a Jedi Knights 4 in the works.

Force Unleashed Anyone?

Arátoeldar · 03-21-2007, 12:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilentScope001

You know, technically, we already got a Jedi Knights 4 in the works.

Force Unleashed Anyone?

I really hope that Force Unleashed comes out on the PC.

**Char Ell** · 03-21-2007, 12:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilentScope001

You know, technically, we already got a Jedi Knights 4 in the works.

Force Unleashed Anyone?

Hmmm.... Well... If Star Wars: The Force Unleashed is Jedi Knights 4 then why isn't it called Star Wars Jedi Knights IV: The Force Unleashed?

Oh yes. I voted for KotOR 3 over JK 4.

SilentScope001 · 03-21-2007, 01:09 AM

Quote:

Hmmm.... Well... If Star Wars: The Force Unleashed is Jedi Knights 4 then why isn't it called Star Wars Jedi Knights IV: The Force Unleashed?

Well, I'm saying it's more of a spirtutal sequel somewhat, which can be considered "Jedi Knights 4".

The reason it's not called Jedi Knights 4...is because, techincally, you aren't playing a Jedi Knight. You're playing Vader's lapdog.

Canderous_ordo1 · 03-21-2007, 04:24 AM

from what i know there is going to be kotor 13 or 19 ive read all 19 books on kotor and everyone is better then the last so if the games are as good as the books well goto admit its better then jedi knight

Arátoeldar · 03-21-2007, 11:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilentScope001

Well, I'm saying it's more of a spirtutal sequel somewhat, which can be considered "Jedi Knights 4".

The reason it's not called Jedi Knights 4...is because, techincally, you aren't playing a Jedi Knight. You're playing Vader's lapdog.

Exactly just like BioShock is the spiritual successor to System Shock.

Titanius Anglesmith · 03-21-2007, 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Canderous_ordo1

from what i know there is going to be kotor 13 or 19 ive read all 19 books on kotor and everyone is better then the last so if the games are as good as the books well goto admit its better then jedi knight

Let's wait until KotOR 3 comes out before we start any talk about games in the double digits.

adamqd · 03-21-2007, 05:12 PM

I've played both and I like both, but for different reasons. I don't see why either can't continue.

Can't we have our cake and eat it?

Darca Lar · 03-21-2007, 08:42 PM

Usually yes, but have too much cake and you'll become ill.^_^

PoiuyWired · 03-22-2007, 03:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SilentScope001

Well, I'm saying it's more of a spirtutal sequel somewhat, which can be considered "Jedi Knights 4".

The reason it's not called Jedi Knights 4...is because, techincally, you aren't playing a Jedi Knight. You're playing Vader's lapdog.

Well, actually we don't even have Jedi Knight 3. JA is a spin-off, and not JK3. So any new JK series game would be JK3, or more correctly DF4.

And yes, FU is definitely not a JK, its quite different actually, from the story point of view, and probably more different than that. I mean, I don't even think you get a blaster this time.

On the side note, I really hope we will be seeing a Ventress this time. I mean she is kinda tough and undestructable. 3 kills by Anakin, and 1 kill by ObiWan(?)

KyleOfHarpenden · 03-25-2007, 11:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PoiuyWired

Well, actually we don't even have Jedi Knight 3. JA is a spin-off, and not JK3. So any new JK series game would be JK3, or more correctly DF4.

And yes, FU is definitely not a JK, its quite different actually, from the story point of view, and probably more different than that. I mean, I don't even think you get a blaster this time.

On the side note, I really hope we will be seeing a Ventress this time. I mean she is kinda tough and undestructable. 3 kills by Anakin, and 1 kill by ObiWan(?)

yeah but even though jka wasn't really jk3 most people think it is but you get the idea another jka game was what i meant

***Jeff*** · 03-25-2007, 02:50 PM

I've honestly never played any of the Jedi Knight games so I'd definitely go with KoToR 3.

Lubaka · 03-30-2007, 05:03 AM

I love and both, but I don't look nothing new of Jedi Knight

Lord Foley · 03-30-2007, 11:03 AM

KotOR III. It will own your soul.

RobQel-Droma · 03-30-2007, 01:07 PM

KOTOR III. Both of them should be made, but KOTOR takes the priority. JK just isn't as good.

However, if they do make JK IV, they need to improve the graphics drastically, make the combat a bit better, way improve the story (from JA, that is), and of course bring the main character back to Kyle. (trust me, Aratoeldar, Kyle Katarn is what the JK series is all about

)

Jediphile · 03-31-2007, 03:18 PM

Well, of course we support K3 here, because:

1. It's a KotOR forum.

2. TSL ends in a cliffhanger while JA does not.

Point Man · 03-31-2007, 10:38 PM

Knights 3 FTW!

Jediphile · 04-01-2007, 05:56 AM

Well, I guess we can call this one off... 99 votes for K3 (91.67%) and merely 9 votes (8.33%) for JK4... Unless JK fans suddenly begin spamming this topic, I guess K3 is the undisputed winner here.

Darca Lar · 04-01-2007, 11:24 PM

no doubt!

kotor_freak · 04-12-2007, 08:35 AM

Just posted my vote. I think we can see what the public wants

It's just the matter if what the public wants, is what the public gets.