Deadeye Dave (?) doesn't know who Pegnose Pete really is... or rather, he doesn't know how to put two and two together. He knows of a customer who buys a lot of prosthetic noses, but he knows him by another name.
Since he is blind, Deadeye Dave's other senses are stronger. He can hear better, and smell better...
------------------

Energizer Bunny arrested, charged with battery.