Whos better, Carth or Atton?

[Blix]

I'll reinforce my opinion from 2010: Carth is too whiny and dramatic for my tastes, Atton all the way.

[Tyvark]

I'd have to put them in an arena and see who survives.

[thejman217]

Atton definitely. I respect carth and his loyalties, but I prefer to serve something while ALIVE, not dead. Meaning, if I was given the opportunity to be fully committed to something, I would do it. However, of it put my life in danger, then I wouldn't follow it, unlike carth. I'm not willing to die for ANYTHING other than family. Atton, when he realizes he's in danger, he knows how and when to leave. I like that I a person. Plus, atton is a (lost) jedi, and carth is not. I like Jedi better than normal people. Plus, atton is not whiny unless he's yelling at kreia.

[Bob Saget]

For me this is kind of a simple question...

Throughout Kotor, you get Carth questioning your loyalty and how he doesn't trust you at all. While personally it is fun grilling him and making fun of him, his character is just not that well defined. It's kind of hard to trust a guy who doesn't trust you.

On the other hand, you have Atton whom you don't know anything about at first, is pretty handy in sticky situations and is really great at certain moments. Especially when you find out about his past, that's where his character takes off.

So IMO, Atton is better

[starwarzchick112]

I said it on KFM and I'll say it here: ATTON ALL THE WAY! It really pisses me off when people go "oh, he's so evil the exile should run!" when everybody supports Luke/Mara, which is pretty much the same thing.

[LDR]

Neither.

HK-47 for life.

It's the logical choice, gentlemen.

However, I'd probably be for Carth. His situation is understandable. Besides, wouldn't you be rather pissed if your mentor betrayed and killed you family and then bombed your homeworld? (Think off them, per se, razing Earth.)

Of course, he whines, but you eventually gain his trust, so...

[*~*Darth pOOba*~*]

Carth, hands down. His voice is sexy! And he's one of those war heroes who was damage emotionally... Which just made him more hot. Oh and he was a great person too

[DarthMourlock]

As a companion, Carth, he's the typical loyal guy who will do anything for his friend.

For interesting dialogue, Atton without question. Atton's dialogue in KOTOR 2 by far surpasses anything Carth ever says to you. The part where Atton explains in detail how to kill a Jedi was just creepy, great writing right there.

[Qui-Don Jorn]

Atton is better than Carth. TSL is better than KotOR.